Alberta's Housing Success Highlights Ontario's Challenges in Home Production

📅 1 day ago
Alberta's Housing Success Highlights Ontario's Challenges in Home Production

A comparative analysis of housing production in Alberta and Ontario reveals significant disparities due to regulatory environments and costs. Alberta's streamlined processes and lower fees have led to increased housing starts, while Ontario struggles with delays and high costs.

For years, Ontario has discussed the urgent need to enhance its housing supply, yet Alberta has exemplified how modifying policy and regulatory frameworks can lead to tangible results. The growing disparity in housing production between these two provinces is becoming increasingly evident. Alberta has ramped up its housing output, while Ontario is experiencing a decline. The primary factors contributing to this gap are policy-driven expenses, approval delays, and regulatory complexities, rather than the fundamental costs associated with construction itself.
In 2025, Alberta initiated a record-breaking 54,858 housing units, marking a 15 percent increase from the previous year's total of 47,827. In contrast, Ontario, which has approximately three times Alberta's population, commenced 65,376 housing units—this figure represents a reduction of over 12 percent from 74,573 starts in 2024 and is dramatically lower than the 99,566 homes initiated in 2021. The city-level comparison reveals an even more striking contrast: Calgary's metropolitan area began construction on 27,684 homes in 2025, surpassing Toronto's 26,087, despite Toronto's significantly larger population.
In the first half of 2026, Calgary saw a remarkable rate of housing starts, averaging 61 homes for every 10,000 residents, while Toronto achieved a mere 19 in the same time frame. This stark difference should serve as a critical warning for Ontario. A delegation from the Residential Construction Council of Ontario (RESCON) recently visited Alberta to understand the factors enabling its residential construction sector to deliver housing more efficiently and affordably. Their tour included visits to off-site construction facilities, master-planned communities, and manufacturing sites, examining how housing is planned, approved, and the associated costs.
The findings from this excursion were illuminating. Alberta has cultivated a housing production ecosystem that is effectively oriented towards expediting home construction. In contrast, Ontario continues to impose additional costs, regulations, delays, and uncertainties on its housing projects. Consider the financial implications: the average cost of a new dwelling in Ontario includes an estimated $380,921 in direct and indirect taxes, fees, and levies, accounting for 35.6 percent of the final purchase price. For instance, municipal fees for a low-rise unit in Toronto were reported at $195,300 in 2024, whereas Calgary's fees were only $93,000. In the case of high-rise units, Toronto's fees reached $134,900, compared to a mere $11,100 in Calgary.
Taxation also exacerbates the disparity. New homes in Ontario are generally subject to a 13 percent HST, despite a temporary rebate scheduled to expire at the end of March, while Alberta applies a lower five percent GST. For a buyer of a $1.25 million home in Toronto, the provincial and municipal land transfer taxes can total approximately $43,000, whereas Alberta's equivalent land-title registration charge is significantly lower.
Ontario Housing Minister Rob Flack has initiated unprecedented reforms aimed at addressing these issues, but he requires the backing of all stakeholders involved. The timeline for obtaining approvals remains excessively lengthy, averaging 25 months in Toronto compared to just 4.2 months in Calgary. Ontario's approval process often involves a convoluted array of municipal departments, regional governments, conservation authorities, transportation agencies, school boards, utilities, and various regulatory bodies, which can result in projects being referred to the Ontario Land Tribunal, further complicating timelines.
While Calgary's regulatory environment is far from lax, it illustrates that governments can establish standards while still making prompt decisions. Importantly, evidence indicates that Ontario's housing cost challenges are not solely attributable to the basic costs of materials or construction productivity; rather, a significant portion of Alberta's advantage stems from factors within governmental control, such as taxes, development charges, approval timelines, infrastructure planning, and regulatory efficiency.
Ontario, therefore, has viable options to enhance its housing landscape. First, the province should consider making development-charge reductions permanent and ensure that municipalities receive stable infrastructure funding from a broader tax base, thereby alleviating the burden on future homebuyers. Second, any relief on HST for new homes should be made permanent and designed to accommodate high-rise condominium and rental projects, which typically require longer construction timelines. Additionally, Ontario must establish firm, legislated approval timelines to prevent applications from stagnating indefinitely.
The harmonization of design and building standards across the province, as well as alignment with national codes where feasible, is also essential. This includes enabling single-stair residential buildings of up to six storeys and eliminating redundant municipal requirements that duplicate existing building code provisions. Financing mechanisms need reform as well, with provincial and federal governments collaborating with lenders and insurers to revitalize stalled high-rise projects through insured construction financing and greater flexibility in converting condominium developments to rental housing.
Finally, Ontario must prioritize infrastructure and workforce development to support growth. This entails planning for water and wastewater capacity proactively, increasing the training of skilled construction workers, and removing barriers to factory-built and modular housing. If the goal is to increase housing availability, an economic and regulatory environment conducive to construction is paramount. Alberta serves as a compelling case study on the positive outcomes that can arise when housing policies, approval processes, and costs are better synchronized with production needs. Ontario should take heed of these lessons.
🏷️ Alberta Housing Approvals Ontario development charges construction costs Infrastructure housing policy RESCON housing production Regulatory Environment

← Previous Post

ThirdGen Timber Group Expands with Strategic Acquisitions of Timber Brands

1 day ago

Next Article →

Parliament Approves 2026 Federal Budget Focused on Infrastructure and Economic Growth

1 day ago

Related Posts